Which would you choose?

OK - you are a CCHS student, and you need to do research for your term paper. You go to the CCHS Library webpage and you need to find information to support your topic.
Which interface is more welcoming? Friendly? More appealing?

On the top is our new draft. On the bottom is the old version.

We unveil our new version in a couple of weeks, and will run them side-by-side, seeking student feedback.

Should be interesting!